In the ever-fluctuating landscape of global finance, few voices command the level of attention that Goldman Sachs strategist Scott Rubner’s doesRecently, Rubner, the firm’s Managing Director and expert in global markets, issued a stark warning that has captured the attention of investors and market analysts alikeHis recent communication, which he described as his “last bullish email” of the year, marks a significant pivot in his previously optimistic stance on U.S. equitiesThis shift has profound implications for the market, signaling potential turbulence ahead.

For most of 2025, Rubner had maintained an optimistic outlook on the U.S. stock marketHowever, his latest analysis suggests that an impending bear market could soon take holdThe dynamics within the market, once buoyed by consistent enthusiasm for buying on dips, are now showing signs of stressAccording to Rubner, the current market is overcrowded with participantsRetail traders, 401(k) funds, and corporate entities are all active in the market, but this enthusiasm is beginning to fadeThe capital flow, which had once powered sustained market rallies, is now shifting, and the uncertainty surrounding seasonal factors only adds to the growing sense of unease.

The S&P 500, a barometer for the broader U.S. stock market, has seen a modest 3% increase since the beginning of the yearDespite this uptick, the market’s recent trading pattern has been notably sideways since December, indicating a lack of clear directionThe resilience of the market, particularly in response to significant events such as inflation reports or concerns over trade tariffs, has surprised many analystsOn the surface, it appears that the market is holding strong in the face of economic challenges, demonstrating a remarkable ability to bounce back from intraday lows following negative news.

However, Rubner takes a contrarian viewHe suggests that the ability to generate excess returns through aggressive dip-buying is on the wane

Advertisements

The market, according to Rubner, is no longer as responsive to these buying opportunities as it once wasOne of the key indicators he points to is the shift in behavior among trend-following tradersRubner highlights an asymmetrical bias, where trend traders are more likely to position themselves for a market decline than a rallyThis creates a precarious imbalance in the market, which Rubner estimates could result in $61 billion in potential sales by commodity trading advisors (CTAs) should the market fall, while a rally would only see $10 billion in purchases.

Corporate stock buybacks, a strategy used by companies to repurchase their own shares and thus reduce the available supply, have played a critical role in supporting the marketBy decreasing the number of shares in circulation, buybacks help stabilize prices, which can mitigate market volatilityHowever, this key support mechanism is set to face a challenge in the near term, as Rubner points out that the corporate buyback window will close on March 16. Once this window shuts, the absence of corporate buybacks raises important questions about what will replace this stabilizing force.

Meanwhile, Rubner is closely monitoring the activities of hedge funds, which have recently increased their risk exposuresHedge funds have been active in global markets, with net purchases of stocks at their highest levels in two monthsThis surge in hedge fund activity could provide short-term support for the market, pushing stock prices higher in the immediate termHowever, Rubner warns that this behavior could add to market instability in the long runIf sentiment shifts, hedge funds could quickly pull back to mitigate risk, leading to a potentially destabilizing sell-off.

Additionally, Rubner notes the growing presence of retail traders in the market, with an unprecedented surge in retail buying power over the past 22 trading daysRetail investors, traditionally seen as more risk-averse, have become increasingly confident in their buying decisions, particularly when markets experience dips

Advertisements

This shift has led to speculative volumes that have reached historic levels, with some days recording imbalances in retail trading activity not seen beforeHowever, historical patterns suggest that this retail enthusiasm may begin to wane as March approaches, which could take some of the market’s momentum with itThe question, then, becomes: when the retail traders pull back, who will step in to support the market?

Given the complex and shifting dynamics within the U.S. stock market, Rubner has recommended that investors consider adopting bearish strategies as a means of protecting their portfoliosOne such strategy is the use of dual binary options and put spreads on the S&P 500 indexThese tactics can offer investors a way to hedge against potential downturns while limiting their exposure to market declinesAdditionally, Rubner suggests employing back-tested put hedges to lock in profits or minimize losses during periods of market instabilityFor those with a more diversified portfolio, Rubner also proposes considering trades involving the Euro Stoxx 50 index, alongside currency strategies such as the euro-to-dollar exchange rate, to capitalize on the interplay between different markets and currencies.

In this environment, where market forces are shifting unpredictably, these strategies could prove instrumental in navigating the anticipated bear marketInvestors looking to safeguard their assets will need to be vigilant in assessing the market’s evolving dynamics and adjust their approaches accordinglyWhile Rubner’s forecast is far from definitive, it offers a sobering view of the risks ahead, reminding investors that the outlook for U.S. equities is far from certain.

The warning issued by Scott Rubner reflects a broader sense of caution that is increasingly being felt across the financial sectorAfter a prolonged period of market optimism, signs are emerging that the rally could be losing steam, with a number of factors indicating that the next phase could be marked by increased volatility and downward pressure

Advertisements

Advertisements

Advertisements